CDASS vs. Agency-Based Community First Choice: Which is Right for You?

Jan 2, 2026 | Resources

Written by: admin

Colorado offers amazing flexibility for home care. If you want to hire a family member or friend to provide your care, you generally have two “self-directed” options: Consumer Directed Attendant Support Services (CDASS) and the Agency-Based In-Home Support Services (IHSS) model, now available under Community First Choice (CFC).

Many families assume CDASS is the only way to hire a loved one. But CDASS comes with a hidden burden: It requires the patient (or their representative) to become a legal “employer.”

This means managing audits, handling liability insurance, and navigating complex tax allocations. For many families, this turns caregiving into a second full-time job.

There Is a Better Way: The Agency-Based Model

At Caregivers First Choice, we offer the Agency-Based CFC Model. This gives you the best of both worlds: the freedom to hire your loved one, without the stress of running a small business.

Here is the difference:

  • We Are the Employer: We handle the payroll taxes, liability insurance, worker’s compensation, and employment paperwork. You never have to worry about an audit or a tax penalty.
  • You Just Care: Your family member becomes our employee, but they work exclusively for you. You still choose who comes into your home and when, but we handle the HR headaches.
  • Better Support: Because we are an agency, your family caregiver gets access to professional training, RN oversight, and agency support that independent contractors in CDASS don’t get.

Comparison: Who Handles the “Heavy Lifting”?

Feature CDASS Model Caregivers First Choice Agency Model
Hiring Family Yes Yes (We hire them for you)
The Boss You are the legal employer We are the legal employer
Paperwork You manage budget & taxes We handle payroll, taxes, & liability
Backup Care You must find your own backup We provide 24/7 backup support
Training You train your attendant We provide professional training & RN oversight

The “Backup Care” Safety Net

One critical difference often overlooked is safety. In the CDASS model, if your caregiver gets sick or needs a vacation, you are responsible for finding a replacement. If you can’t find one, you may go without care.

In our Agency-Based model, we are required by state regulations to provide backup attendants. If your primary caregiver is unavailable, we have a roster of trained staff ready to step in, ensuring you are never left unsupported.

The Verdict

If you are comfortable managing a monthly budget, handling employment taxes, and recruiting your own backup staff, CDASS is a valid option.

However, if you want to hire a loved one without the stress of administrative liability, the Agency-Based model is the safer, more sustainable choice. You focus on the care; we handle the compliance.

You May Also Like…

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *